Revisiting India’s Neighborhood First Policy in the Context of Growing US China Engagement in Nepal
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.59552/nppr.v3i2.70Keywords:
Eminent Persons Group, Indo-US Partnership, Kalapani-Lipulekh, Neighborhood First Policy, Zone of PeaceAbstract
Where does India’s Neighborhood First policy stand in the context of U.S.-China’s growing strategic engagement in Nepal? It has been realized that Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi's Neighborhood First Policy was unable to deliver on its economic and developmental promises in a multifaceted manner. Mr. Modi’s initial engagements with Nepal were perceived as accommodating policies, and it was believed that they would bring about a “paradigm shift” that would replace the “Nehru Doctrine.” However, going against the spirit of the speech delivered by Mr. Modi in Nepal’s Constituent Assembly, India imposed an unofficial blockade that pulled down Nepal-India relations. Further, Kalapani border disputes and Mr. Modi’s unwillingness to receive the EPG report also added to the trust deficit. The EPG report was expected to reactivate the trust. However, this vacuum gives the U.S. and China an opportunity to increase their strong presence in Nepal. China’s interest in getting access to South Asia via the BRI project overlaps with the MCC. So, their rivalry to create strategic space in Nepal is going on. On the one hand, India has not joined BRI and believes it String of Pearls strategy. Further, the country perceives any development in the Himalayan region as a security threat. On the other hand, India and the U.S. are global allies since China’s takeover of Tibet and they have held similar views on Nepal. Considering the growing bipolar strategic rivalry between China and the U.S., this paper examines where India’s Neighborhood First policy stands and what the state of its implementation will be. This study uses qualitative, exploratory research techniques to analyze the geopolitical relation and diplomacy.
References
Ali, G. (2023). Territorial disputes, the role of leaders and the impact of Quad: a triangular explanation of China-India border escalations. The Pacific Review, 1-23.
Aryal, J. (2019). The nature and impacts of 2015 Indian unofficial blockade in Nepal (Master’s thesis, Norwegian University of Life Sciences, Ås).
Aryal, S. K. (2022). Post-2015 India-Nepal Relations and China Factor in South Asia. Politeja-Pismo Wydziału Studiów Międzynarodowych i Politycznych Uniwersytetu Jagiellońskiego, 19(76), 285-303.
Aryal, S. K. (2022). India’s ‘Neighbourhood First’policy and the Belt & Road Initiative (BRI). Asian Journal of Comparative Politics, 7(4), 744-756.
Aryal, S. K., & Pulami, M. J. (2023). The Trajectory Between Territorial Disputes, Nationalism, and Geopolitics: A Case Study of the Kalapani Border Dispute Between India and Nepal. Geopolitics, 1-23.
Baral, B. N. (2018). Changing dynamics of Nepalese foreign policy: Patterns and trends. Journal of Political Science, 18, 25-45.
Bhattarai, G. (2022). China’s Perception of Nepal-India Relations. In Nepal Between China and India: Difficulty of Being Neutral (pp. 69-104). Cham: Springer International Publishing.
Bhattarai, P. (2018). Negotiating Between Unequal Neighbours: India’s Role in Nepal’s Recent Constitution-Making Process. https://nbn-resolving.org/urn:nbn:de:0168-ssoar-61142-4
Bhattarai, G., & Pulami, M. J. (2022). Mapping Nepal’s Foreign Policy Behaviour towards Great Power Politics: A Study of Nepal’s Foreign Policy Response to the Russia-Ukraine Crisis. Nepal Public Policy Review, 2, 147-179.
Bhattarai, G., & Pulami, M. J. (2022). Madhyama Pratipad: Nepal’s Middle Path Ambition through Non-alignment. Journal of Foreign Affairs, 2(01), 153-173.
Bhusal, J. K. (2020). Evolution of cartographic aggression by India: A study of Limpiadhura to Lipulek. Geographical Journal of Nepal, 13, 47-68.
Chakrabarty, P., & Sadhukhan, S. K. (2020). Destination image for pilgrimage and tourism: A study in Mount Kailash region of Tibet. Folia Geographica, 62(2), 71
Chand, H. P. (2020). Critical Issues Related to Connectivity in South Asia. Journal of International Affairs, 3(1), 68-83.
Chaturvedy, R. R. (2019). Modi’s neighborhood policy and China’s response. Issues & Studies, 55(02), 1940001.
Colley, C. K. (2023). An action-reaction cycle in the Sino-Indian rivalry?. India Review, 22(3), 249-281.
Cowan, S. (2015). The Indian check posts, Lipu Lekh, and Kalapani, Retrieve from https://www.recordnepal.com/indian-checkposts-lipu-lekh-and-kalapani
Dahal, G. (2017). Nepal and India Relation After 12 Points Understanding. Journal of Political Science. 20,61-75
Destradi, S. (2012). India as a democracy promoter? New Delhi’s involvement in Nepal’s return to democracy. Democratization, 19(2), 286-311.
Dharamdasani, M. D. (1979). ‘Zone of Peace’: Nepal’s Quest for Identity. China Report, 15(5), 13-19.
Duggal, M. (2023). India’s Position in a New US–China Cold War: Pointed Alignment Strategy and Middle Power Diplomacy. Indo-Pacific Strategies and Foreign Policy Challenges: The US-China Strategic Competition, 148.
Faisal, M., & Khan, K. (2022). China and South Asia: Challenges, Trends and Trajectory. Китай в мировой и региональной политике. История и современность, 27(27), 145-159.
Foreign Policy. (2023). Why the United States Is Courting Nepal. https://foreignpolicy.com/2023/02/02/nepal-united-states-china-diplomacy-nuland-visit/
Gambhir, M. (2020). India’s Position in South Asia : An Assessment of India’s Neighbourhood First Policy. Centre for Land Warfare Studies (Claws): Issue Brief. https://www.claws.in/static/IB-262_-Indias-Position-in-South-Asia-An-Assessment-of-India%E2%80%99s-Neighbourhood-First-Policy.pdf
Ganguly, S., & Shoup, B. (2005). Nepal: between dictatorship and anarchy. J. Democracy, 16, 129.
Garver, J. W. (1991). China-India rivalry in Nepal: The clash over Chinese arms sales. Asian Survey, 31(10), 956–975. https://doi.org/10.2307/2645066
Ghimire, B. & Pathak, A. (2022). What Lies Behind Modi’s Nepal Visit? The Diplomat. https://thediplomat.com/2022/05/what-lies-behind-modis-nepal-visit/
Ghimire, Y. (Eds.). (2007). Newsfront. 15-28 October 2007, Issue 38. Available at: https://api.repository.cam.ac.uk/server/api/core/bitstreams/af3c963e-7284-4213-9de6-8e6f4ffed38b/content
Giri, A. (2023). PM’s India visit: Some agreements, soft-pedalling of contentious issues. The Kathmandu Post. https://kathmandupost.com/politics/2023/05/28/pm-s-india-visit-some-agreements-soft-pedalling-of-contentious-issues
Gokhale, V. (2021). The road from Galwan: The future of India-China relations. Carnegie Endowment for International Peace (pp. 11–12). Carnegie India.
Gurung, A. M. (2017). The Madhesi Movement in Nepal: A Study on Socio Cultural and Political Aspects, 1990-2015 (Doctoral dissertation).
Gyawali, D. (1989). Water in Nepal: an interdisciplinary look at resource uncertainties, evolving problems, and future prospects.
Hue, Q. T. (2022). India’s foreign policy towards Southeast Asia before Prime Minister Narendra Modi. Jindal Journal of International Affairs, 10(1), 20-35.
Jain, S. (2014). Narendra Modi. World Affairs: The Journal of International Issues, 18(4), 10-25.
Jaiswal, P. (2023). India–China Rivalry in Nepal. In Coping with China-India Rivalry: South Asian Dilemmas (pp. 55-64).
Karki, R., & Paudel, L. (2015). Challenges to the revision of the Nepal–India 1950 peace and friendship treaty. Strategic Analysis, 39(4), 402-416.
Karki, T. (2022). Political Blackmailing: A Case Study of India’s Unofficial Blockade on Nepal. http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4197326
Kaura, V., & Rani, M. (2020). India’s neighbourhood policy during 2014–2019: political context and policy outcomes. Indian Journal of Public Administration, 66(1), 10-27.
Khan, H. (2023). War and Peace in East Asia: Avoiding Thucydides’s Trap with China as a Rising Power.
Khobragade, V. (2016). India–Nepal Relations. World Affairs: The Journal of International Issues, 20(3), 146-163.
Kumar, S. (2011). India and the Himalayan states. In Handbook of India’s international relations (pp. 70-82). Routledge.
Lamichhane, D. P. (2023). American Engagement with Nepal: Concerns of China and India. Unity Journal, 4(1), 280-301.
Lok Sabha Secreatariat (2022). Background Note on India’s ‘Neighbourhood First’ Policy. http://parliamentlibraryindia.nic.in/lcwing/Indias%20neighbourhood.pdf
Maharjan, R. K. (2023). Leveraging Military Diplomacy in Nepal’s Foreign Policy. Unity Journal, 4(01), 94-111.
Mishra, M. K. (2020). India in the Himalayan landscape: Security concerns and approaches. World Affairs: The Journal of International Issues, 24(3), 20–41. https://www.jstor.org/stable/48590641
Mitra, D. (2019). Bilateral Experts Report on New India-Nepal Treaty Likely to Face Roadblocks. https://thewire.in/diplomacy/india-nepal-friendship-treaty
MOFA. (2020). Press Release on Lipu Lekh, https://mofa.gov.np. https://mofa.gov.np/press-release-regarding-lipu-lekh/
MOFA. ( 2022). Press Release on the Official Visit of the Prime Minister of India to Lumbini, Nepal (16 May 2022). https://mofa.gov.np/press-release-on-the-official-visit-of-the-prime-minister-of-india-to-lumbini-nepal-16-may-2022/
Muni, S. D. (2009). India’s Foreign Policy: The democracy dimension. Cambridge University Press.
Murton, G., & Lord, A. (2020). Trans-Himalayan power corridors: Infrastructural politics and China’s belt and road initiative in Nepal. Political Geography, 77, 102100.
My Republica (2019). US Indo-Pacific Command admiral returns home. https://myrepublica.nagariknetwork.com/news/us-indo-pacific-command-admiral-returns-home/
My Republica. (2022). Nepal, India sign, exchange six MoUs/Agrements during PM Modi’s Lumbini visit (With list). https://myrepublica.nagariknetwork.com/news/nepal-india-sign-exchange-six-mous-agrements-during-pm-s-modi-s-lumbini-visit-with-list/
Nayak, S. (2020). India and Nepal’s Kalapani border dispute: An explainer. New Delhi: Observer Research Foundation. Retrieved from Observer Research Foundation.
Neupane, R. (2022). China and India in Nepal: What Does it Entail? (Master’s thesis).
NGA, L. T. H., & Thuong, N. L. T. (2021). India–China Competition in South Asia Under Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s Administration. The Journal of Indian and Asian Studies, 2(01), 2150001.
Oxford Analytica. (2022). Nepali politics will get stormier in lead-up to polls. Emerald Expert Briefings, (oxan-db).
Pathak, B. (2022). The Nepal Compact. Cook Communication.
Pathak, B., & Bastola, S. (2022). Negotiation by Peaceful Means: Nepo-India Territorial Disputes. Cook Communication.
Pyakuryal, B., & Chaturvedi, S. (2016). Prosper thy neighbour: India’s cooperation with Nepal. In India’s Approach to Development Cooperation (pp. 94-109). Routledge.
Ranjan, A. (2019). Neighbourhood First: India’s Policy towards Nepal. Vivekananda International Foundation. https://www.vifindia.org/2019/october/01/neighbourhood-first-india-s-policy-towards-nepal
Ranjan, A., & Gurung, W. F. (2021). The India-China Competition in Nepal in recent years. Artha Journal of Social Sciences, 20(3), 93-111.
Rose, L. E. (1971). Nepal: Strategy for survival (p. 44). University of California Press.
Rose, L. E., & Scholz, J. T. (1980). International relations: A root between two stones. Profile of the Himalayan Kingdom. Westview Press.
Roychoudhury, S., Chenoy, A., Chopra, D., & Joshi, A. (2015). Is Indian Development Cooperation taking a new direction under Modi?.
Sagar, R. P, (2020). Nepal objecting to India’s roadwork at ‘someone else’s behest’: Army chief https://www.theweek.in/news
Sahoo, P. (2016). A history of India’s neighborhood policy. World Affairs: The Journal of International Issues, 20(3), 66–81. https://www.jstor.org/stable/ 48505294
Sapkota, R. (2020). Nepal’s Conundrum in the Indo-Pacific amidst the Emergence of the Great Power Rivalry. Stosunki Międzynarodowe, 56(2), 111-124.
Shah, A., & Karki, S. (2023). Examining the systemic realities of India in the US-backed Indo-Pacific Strategy. Stosunki Międzynarodowe–International Relations, 3, 6.
Shah. B. B. B. (1973). King Birendra’s address to the fourth summit of the non-aligned. Birendra Speaks on Foreign Policy, no. 3, p. 11
Shah, S. H. (2017). Indo-Nepal relations: A bilateral paradox. IUP Journal of International Relations, 11(4), 28-48.
Sharma, S. (2023). 1950 India–Nepal Treaty of Peace and Friendship and Regional Mobilisations in Eastern India. India Quarterly, 79(1), 79-92.
Singh, C. P. (2004, January). Rise and growth of anti-Rana movement in Nepal. In Proceedings
Sinha, R. (2021). Linking Land Borders: India’s Integrated Check Posts. Centre for Social and Economic Progress.
Shivamurthy, A. G., Fazli, Z., Hossain, D., Bhandari, A., Bhattarai, D., Naseem, A., & Attanayake, C. (2022). India-China Competition: Perspectives from the Neighbourhood (No. 197). Special Report.
Subedi, S. (1994). India-Nepal Security Relations and the 1950 Treaty: Time for New Perspectives. Asian Survey, 34(3), 273-284. doi:10.2307/2644985
Suwedy, K. R. (2022). Nepal-India Political Relations 2006-2016 (Doctoral dissertation, Faculty of Humanities and Social Science, Political Science).
Tammen, R. L. (2008). The Organski legacy: A fifty-year research program. International Interactions, 34(4), 314-332.
Tandon, A. (2016). India’s foreign policy priorities and the emergence of a Modi doctrine. Strategic Analysis, 40(5), 349-356.
The Annapurna Express. (2023). US engagement in Nepal. https://theannapurnaexpress.com/news/us-engagement-in-nepal-37650/
The Center for Bangladesh and Global Affairs. (2023). Bangladesh-Nepal Energy Cooperation: Applying the BIN Approach. https://www.cbgabd.org/2023/07/05/
The Diplomat. (2022). Did Wang Yi’s Visit Stem the Slide in China-Nepal Relations? https://thediplomat.com/2022/03/did-wang-yis-visit-stem-the-slide-in-china-nepal-relations/
The Kathmandu Post. (2023). US Under Secretary of State for Political Affairs Victoria Nuland arrives today. https://kathmandupost.com/national/2023/01/29/us-under-secretary-of-state-for-political-affairs-victoria-nuland-arrives-today
The Kathmandu Post. (2023). Protect sovereignty while engaging neighbours, says top US diplomat. https://kathmandupost.com/politics/2023/01/31/protect-sovereignty-while-engaging-neighbours-says-top-us-diplomat
The Kathmandu Post. (2023). Nepal seeks 25-year bilateral deal with India to sell power. https://kathmandupost.com/money/2023/04/02/nepal-seeks-25-year-bilateral-deal-with-india-to-sell-power
Timalsina, S. K. (2019). Nepal-India Relations: Efforts to Review 1950‟ s Treaty (Special Acts of EPG). International Journal of Innovative Science and Research Technology, 4(6), 729-735.
Times Now Digital, (2018). PM Modi in Nepal HIGHLIGHTS: PM Modi addresses the inaugural session of BIMSTEC summit in Kathmandu, https://www.timesnownews.com.
Vindegg, M. (2022). Borderline politics: Reading Nepal-India relations as ‘energohistory’. History and Anthropology, 1-20.
Wani, T. R. (2015). India’s Prime Minister Narendra Modi Visit to Nepal: Renewing Relations. International Journal of Scientific and Research Publications, 584.
Yang, S. Y. (2013). Power transition, balance of power, and the rise of china: a theoretical reflection about rising great powers. China Review, 13(2), 35-66.
Yhome, K. (2019). ‘Neighbourhood First’ policy in the changing regional geopolitics. Observer Research Foundation. https://www.orfonline.org/expert-speak/neighbourhood-first-policy-in-the-changing-regional-geopolitics-55887/
Additional Files
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2023 Dron Prasad Lamichhane
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
